Preprint Server arXiv Friendly Journals

arXiv Loving Journals

Which Journals Are Okay With Preprint Servers like arXiv?

Publication in Genetics/Genomics is seriously thinking of embracing what Physicists have been doing for  a while, that is making their papers available online on preprint servers like arXiv before the peer-reviewed publication.  In the era where social media rules, the preprint servers offer a great opportunity to increase the reach of the paper, get fast feedback, and improve the quality of the paper.  This is a huge change and not all journals (or scientists) have warmed up to the idea of pre-publishing on preprint servers.

Preprint Friendly Journals

Top journals like Science and Nature have a clear policy on accepting non-profit preprint articles, but other specialized journals have yet to come up with a clear policy.  Here is our effort to compile the list of journals that are preprint server friendly and collate their policies.

Hope that the list grows and help the researchers to try the open-review preprint servers like arXiv before publishing in their domain of journals.  Please help to populate the “preprint server friendly” journal list.

Science

We do not consider manuscripts that have been previously published elsewhere. Posting of a paper on the Internet may be considered prior publication that could compromise the originality of the Science submission, although we do allow posting on not-for-profit preprint servers in many cases. Please contact the editors for advice about specific cases. We provide a free electronic reprint service to authors that allows visitors to the authors’ web site free access to the published version of the Sciencepaper on Science Online immediately after publication.

Nature

Nature does not wish to hinder communication between scientists. For that reason, different embargo guidelines apply to work that has been discussed at a conference or displayed on a preprint server and picked up by the media as a result. (Neither conference presentations nor posting on recognized preprint servers constitute prior publication.)

PNAS

Preprints have a long and notable history in science, and it has been PNAS policy that they do not constitute prior publication. This is true whether an author hands copies of a manuscript to a few trusted colleagues or puts it on a publicly accessible web site for everyone to read, as is common now in parts of the physics community. The medium of distribution is not germane. A preprint is not considered a publication because it has not yet been formally reviewed and it is often not the final form of the paper. Indeed, a benefit of preprints is that feedback usually leads to an improved published paper or to no publication because of a revealed flaw. Analogous to a preprint is the often detailed oral presentation of work at a conference. Once again we do not view this as prior publication but as a salutary step toward publication.

Oxford Journals

For the majority of Oxford Journals, prior to acceptance for publication, authors retain the right to make a pre-print [A preprint is defined here as un-refereed author version of the article] version of the article available on your own personal website and/or that of your employer and/or in free public servers of preprints and/or articles in your subject area, provided that where possible.

PLOS ONE

PLOS ONE does not accept for publication work that has already been published elsewhere in the peer-reviewed literature. We will consider manuscripts that have been deposited in preprint servers such as arXiv.

[Update]

With in a week after this post, twitter inspired crowd-sourced effort by many helped to create a useful wikipage with the list of journals and its preprint policies. Check here to learn more.

Speak Your Mind

*